Menu

Monday Tip-Off: Is The Past My Basketball Gaming Future?

Monday Tip-Off: Is The Past My Basketball Gaming Future?

We’re at midcourt, and the ball is about to go up…it’s Monday Tip-Off! Join me as I begin the week here at the NLSC with my opinions and commentary on basketball gaming topics, as well as tales of the fun I’ve been having on the virtual hardwood. This week, I’m tipping things off with some thoughts about whether playing games from the past and enjoying historical rosters is the future of my basketball gaming.

More than a week after NBA 2K27’s release, I still don’t have the game. Thinking back, the last time that I didn’t get a new game at launch would’ve been NBA Live 2002 back in 2001, and that’s only because it was a Christmas present along with my PlayStation 2. To that end, it’s been 25 years since I’ve waited this long post-launch to pick up the latest basketball video game. Even when I had to wait longer for a game to come out here in Australia, I was still getting it on what was Day 1 for us, or within a week or so at the very least.

Funnily enough, I’ve rather enjoyed connecting with Dee to play NBA 2K27 over Parsec. In fact, I’m optimistic that I might like it more than its recent predecessors based on my experiences so far. It’s possible that by taking a break from playing the latest NBA 2K, it finally feels fresh enough to dive back in. At the same time, leaning into my predisposition for retro gaming has also made me extremely comfortable with playing old favourites and developing an appreciation for classics that I overlooked. Indeed, the longer that I delay picking up NBA 2K27, the more that I wonder if I’ve reached a point where the future of my basketball gaming actually lies in the past.

As much as I have absolutely no shame about retro basketball gaming and I’ll keenly advocate for it, I’m aware of the stigma. If nothing else, I don’t relish the thought of proving all those snarky comments about retro gamers being stuck in the past to be accurate! More than that though, it’s a dismaying thought to consider that new games just may not be for me anymore. After all, the latest generation of NBA 2K games are doing some cool things – at least on paper – and I’d like to get excited about that. The fact that I didn’t immediately dislike NBA 2K27 as I suspected I would considering its similarity to recent games is quite promising, but again, I’m not rushing out to buy it.

Jaylen Brown in NBA 2K27

Mind you, that’s in large part due to protest and pragmatism. As I’ve discussed at length before, I’ve been extremely disappointed by the current generation of NBA 2K games. For me, there’s been little value in picking them up beyond news coverage and content creation purposes. And yet, I’ve been pre-ordering them at full price (or at a very small discount) for years now. Delaying my purchase of NBA 2K27 for as long as I possibly can – and hopefully getting it on sale – while still getting to play it with an assist from Dee and making use of official screenshots for news bulletins, feels like I’m taking a stand and being a savvy consumer in the process. That’s rather satisfying!

Of course, it also speaks to how I don’t feel like I’m missing out by not having the latest game at my disposal, despite my positive first impressions. There are reasons for that, of course. While I’ve enjoyed connecting with Dee to play some exhibition games, I have my concerns about the modes that I’d traditionally be interested in. MyCAREER has turned into an MMORPG, with a long grind that’ll be all for nothing once the servers are shut down. The same goes for MyTEAM, not to mention the greed of its loot box mechanics. I’d love to get into MyNBA Eras, but the inaccuracies throughout the rosters and branding changes dampens my enthusiasm for the concept.

In short, while I’ve found the on-court experience to be surprisingly more palatable than I’d anticipated, I may not end up hooked on NBA 2K27. I’m not confident that it will be much better than its immediate predecessors at holding my interest for long enough to justify picking it up at full price. That brings me to my preference for retro basketball gaming in recent years. It’s kept me thoroughly entertained, whether I’m revisiting old favourites, dipping into the collection to give titles that I overlooked a second chance, starting a season, or just playing exhibition games. I’ve had way more fun doing that than trying to make the best of new releases that I have issues with.

Past Meets Future in NBA Live 19 Ultimate Team

Now, not loving the latest release and preferring to stick with a game that you do like – even if it’s a couple of years old – isn’t anything new. Historically, a lot of people in our community have done that, and it’s why many classics continue to be modded for several years after their release. The fact that I’ve preferred to stick with old favourites for basically an entire generation is concerning though, even with my predisposition for retro gaming. In years gone by, there were always games here or there that weren’t a hit with me – and often others as well – but I went on to enjoy games that came out after them, and looked forward to the future. Nowadays, I’m no longer as optimistic.

Let’s also address the elephant in the room: my interest in (or lack thereof) the current NBA. For some years now, I haven’t felt as engaged with or entertained by the NBA as I once was. From the style of play and personalities of the players to unnecessary format changes and discourse based around hot takes and disrespect for history, my enjoyment of the current NBA has waned throughout the 2020s. It doesn’t help that the Chicago Bulls have been terrible and directionless either, though the arrival of Caleb Wilson might invigorate the team and reignite my interest. I’d prefer not to be so jaded – the old head grumbling about the modern game – but frankly, it’s difficult.

To that point, one of the major benefits of getting a new basketball game every year is that we can play with updated rosters and the new rookie crop in an official capacity. Obviously our modding community has proven itself adept at updating the previous year’s game or an even older title for the upcoming season time and time again, but there have been limitations. A new game updates the setting for the first season in its franchise and career modes, ensures that the new rookies have faces and audio, and generally provides authenticity that’s impossible to achieve via modding. Annual titles are more than “just a roster update”, but that roster update is still a major selling point.

Revisiting the Past in NBA 2K9

If your interest in the current NBA has diminished as mine has though, then needless to say, that aspect of annual releases likewise loses its appeal. Conversely, dusting off old favourites allows me to play with rosters that I’m more familiar with and have a much greater affinity for. Sure, the historical content in contemporary NBA 2K titles offers similar opportunities and interesting ways to indulge nostalgia, from MyNBA Eras to the various modes of play in MyTEAM. In many cases though, those older titles provide a gameplay experience that I prefer, even if it isn’t as technologically advanced. They’re from an era where I felt more positive about the NBA and gaming.

I’ve also developed a much greater interest in exploring NBA history beyond my own nostalgia over the past year or so. Although I’ve always respected the greats that came before my time and enjoy seeing them represented on the virtual hardwood, whenever I’ve played with historical content, it’s usually been teams and players from the era I grew up watching. It’s been rewarding to broaden my gaming horizons, and indulge my passion for NBA history. Again, I could do that in NBA 2K27, but retro gaming with Legends is nostalgia on top of nostalgia. It’s why when I think of roster modding projects I’d like to tackle, historical mods for old favourites are what come to mind.

By playing with Legends from before my time – and even those from the eras that I’m nostalgic for – I’ve been able to enjoy historical content that I’ve overlooked because I was playing with contemporary rosters or levelling up a MyPLAYER. This satisfies a desire that I have regarding my entertainment these days. It’s not that I’m uninterested in new things, but I’ve reached a point where I’m eager to experience video games, TV shows, and movies that I’ve never gotten around to playing and watching. As far as hoops titles, my collection gives me plenty of options! Even in favourites that I’ve spent countless hours with, there’s content and modes that I’ve never really touched.

Michael Jordan vs. Gary Payton in NBA Live 06 PC

With that in mind, it does feel like the past is my basketball gaming future, or will at least be a major part of it. Whether it’s making new memories in old favourites, new retro kicks, or playing with historical content in classics and future releases alike, my enjoyment of virtual basketball is going to involve the past in some way. As I said, it’s tough to say that without sounding like I’m stuck in the past, though I’ve also reached a point where I don’t really care if I sound like an uncool old person! I just want to enjoy my hobbies now and in the future, and if that means indulging my nostalgia for basketball and basketball gaming’s past, so be it! We should all play what we want.

Still, even though I’m ultimately comfortable with the idea that the past is the future of my basketball gaming, I’m also wistful about it. I don’t enjoy that I don’t anticipate new games the way that I used to. It’s not fun to feel so cynical and pessimistic every preview season, though the games and the way they’re promoted are responsible for that. It’s unfortunate that one of the reasons the past feels more appealing is that the direction of the genre has hinted at a future that’s bleakly sterile, and hostile to long-time fans. The same goes for real basketball. You never want to be the grumpy old person grumbling about how things used to be better, but there’s some truth to that!

I’ll definitely be picking up NBA 2K27 at some point. I remain a collector, and it’s also a necessary investment for the site. Even if I do enjoy it more than the last few releases however, I’d be surprised if I’m not back to retro basketball gaming sooner rather than later. Furthermore, I’m not sure if any future releases will be able to fully overcome my enthusiasm for the past, and delight me the same way as new and old favourites. I won’t dismiss the possibility, but a backlog of games and unexplored modes and content beckons. You can call retro gaming being stuck in the past, but as long as I’m having fun, it’s far preferable to not seeing any future in my hobby at all.

Support The NLSC on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!
Subscribe
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments