Wayback Wednesday: NBA’s Greatest in NBA 2K12

NBA's Greatest Menu in NBA 2K12

This is Wayback Wednesday, your midweek blast from the past! In this feature, we dig into the archives, look back at the history of basketball gaming, and indulge in some nostalgia. Check in every Wednesday for retrospectives and other features on older versions of NBA Live, NBA 2K, and old school basketball video games in general. You’ll also find old NLSC editorials re-published with added commentary, and other flashback content.

I’ve been watching some classic NBA games recently, and it got me in the mood to play with some retro teams in NBA 2K. I can do that in NBA 2K16 of course, but only NBA 2K11 and NBA 2K12 have dedicated modes for the historic squads, namely the Jordan Challenge and NBA’s Greatest respectively. After catching Michael Jordan’s 63 point game against Larry Bird’s Boston Celtics, I originally opted for NBA 2K11, with an eye towards finishing the Jordan Challenge games I never completed. When that didn’t go so well, I turned my attention towards NBA 2K12, and my unfinished challenges in NBA’s Greatest.

I’d ultimately complete my unfinished business, clearing all of the remaining challenges over the weekend. I found myself having a lot of fun, and the experience certainly made me appreciate NBA’s Greatest all over again. In fact, it had me wishing that we still had some sort of mode for the classic teams in the newer games. Since I’ve finally completed all fifteen games and unlocked all of the included retro teams at long last, it only made sense to profile NBA’s Greatest for this week’s Wayback Wednesday feature.

Let’s take a look back…way back…

With the success of the Jordan Challenge in NBA 2K11, and a lockout looming over the 2012 season, Visual Concepts doubled down on historical content in NBA 2K12 with NBA’s Greatest. Whereas the Jordan Challenge had been centred on Michael Jordan – obviously – NBA’s Greatest not only spotlighted MJ, but fourteen other NBA Legends: Magic Johnson, Larry Bird, Julius Erving, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Wilt Chamberlain, Bill Russell, Oscar Robertson, Hakeem Olajuwon, Karl Malone, Patrick Ewing, Scottie Pippen, Jerry West, and John Stockton.

Michael Jordan in an NBA's Greatest game in NBA 2K12

Unlike the Jordan Challenge, which represented specific games and challenged gamers to match MJ’s statistical marks, the games in NBA’s Greatest were simply match-ups between one of the Legends’ squads, and a historically significant opponent from the same season. The only objective was to win the game with the Legend’s team, in the process unlocking both squads for use in exhibition play. While this change came as a disappointment in some respects, it did make the challenges more straightforward, and the games themselves were still fun. Quarter length could also be changed, after being locked to eight minutes in the Jordan Challenge.

While the Jordan Challenge included all of the most significant players on its historical teams, more than a couple of teams were heavy on fictional placeholder players. For NBA’s Greatest, Visual Concepts managed to get at least eight real players on each squad, though placeholder players still rounded out all of the teams. The more authentic rosters unquestionably added to the experience, and facilitated modding projects, notably the original Ultimate Base Roster. Charles Barkley was (unsurprisingly) the only big name who wasn’t included; as a result, he’s missing from the ’85 Philadelphia 76ers, and Jordan’s challenge instead pits the ’93 Chicago Bulls against the ’93 Charlotte Hornets.

While the games were fun to play, the lasting legacy of NBA’s Greatest has to be what it managed to achieve in terms of its presentation, which was just spectacular. Each game featured presentation that was styled after an NBA television broadcast of its era. This not only included the overlays, but also visual and audio effects. The earliest game – Bill Russell’s challenge set in the 1965 season – is in black and white. 70s and 80s games have washed out colours and a fuzzier picture, with the mid to late 90s games looking much better. If you go back and watch real games from those eras, you’ll see how accurate the visual effects and overlays are, minus network branding.

Magic Johnson vs. Larry Bird in NBA's Greatest in NBA 2K12

In terms of the commentary, NBA’s Greatest is presented as Kevin Harlan, Clark Kellogg, and Steve Kerr commentating on an old game from the archives. This is an excellent way of handling the situation: not only does it preserve a sense of historical accuracy, but also realism, as Steve Kerr himself is an active participant in some of the games. It also allows the trio to mention trivia and comment on the players’ overall careers, so it’s a nice history lesson as you play. From the moment it was announced, I felt that retrospective commentary was the right approach, and it worked out really well.

Dusting off NBA 2K11 and NBA 2K12 over the weekend, I did struggle a little at first. It’s been some time since I played either game regularly, so it took me a while to reacquaint myself with the controls, which have changed significantly in recent years. I realise this may be a controversial opinion, because we’re talking about two great games that are still many people’s favourites, but I feel that NBA 2K11 and NBA 2K12 really don’t hold up that well in that regard, with some clunky controls and player movement. Shooting mechanics have also gotten a lot better since then.

That being said, after playing a few games of NBA 2K12 and running through the Training Camp tutorials again, I did get a better handle on the controls. While I still don’t like them as much as the Pro Stick and other controls in recent games, I did find myself getting used to them again, and playing much better as a result. The first couple of games I played were Patrick Ewing and Hakeem Olajuwon’s challenges, and without a good handle on the controls, they certainly were challenging. However, once I was more comfortable with them, I won most of the games more handily, only having to repeat Jerry West’s challenge. Those ’71 Atlanta Hawks put up a good fight!

1960s Presentation in NBA's Greatest (NBA 2K12)

It was certainly interesting to go back and play with those teams from the 70s, when there was no three-point line. You don’t realise how much you miss having that weapon in your arsenal until it’s gone. A couple of quick threes can build a lead or erase a deficit in short order, so without the arc, you’ve got to work harder to put points up on the board, while also really knuckling down on defense. I did find myself making some shots from what would have been three-point range, and indeed, hit a shot after the buzzer with Jerry West that would’ve forced overtime, had it come in time and the three-point line been in effect. It was a tough way to lose.

Since I have a lot of nostalgia for the 90s, I definitely enjoyed playing those games the most. Oddly, at times NBA’s Greatest actually delivers more nostalgia with the key role players and bench players than the big names. It’s obviously a blast to play with Michael Jordan, Scottie Pippen, Hakeem Olajuwon, and so on, while taking on greats like David Robinson, Tim Duncan, Dikembe Mutombo, Shaquille O’Neal, and Kobe Bryant. However, you’re always going to remember those players. It’s kind of cool to see Bryant Stith, Matt Bullard, Adam Keefe, Jeff Turner, LaPhonso Ellis, Reggie Williams, Johnny Newman et al, and think “Oh yeah, I remember those guys!”

Simply put, NBA’s Greatest is one of the best modes we’ve seen in a basketball game, and just what NBA 2K12 needed to deliver some fresh content while we waited for the lockout of 2011 to be resolved. I do have to say that in going back to NBA 2K12 over the weekend, I now have a greater appreciation for some of the significant improvements that have been made in recent releases. If nothing else, I prefer right stick dribbling controls, so NBA 2K12 isn’t a game I’m likely to revisit too often. However, I’m glad I went back and took care of some unfinished business with NBA’s Greatest. It’s a mode that’s definitely worth completing, and fondly looking back on.

Support The NLSC on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
September 3, 2016 5:37 am

Great read. I loved that mode. Hopefully 2K brings it back one day.